The California Racial Justice Act: From 2020 to the Present

racial justice act hero

A History of Racial Injustice

In 1987, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a landmark decision in McCleskey v. Kemp, establishing a legal precedent that left courts unable to effectively address racial discrimination and bias in criminal cases. Originating in Georgia, this case involved Warren McCleskey, a Black man sentenced to death for the murder of a white police officer. During his appeal, McCleskey presented extensive statistical evidence showing that defendants accused of killing white victims, particularly Black defendants, were significantly more likely to receive the death penalty. However, in a 5–4 decision, the Court ruled that statistical evidence alone was insufficient to prove unconstitutional racial discrimination and that defendants must show intentional discrimination in their individual case.

Despite documented racial disparities in charging decisions, jury selection, courtroom conduct, and sentencing outcomes, courts have often rejected these claims because of the nearly impossible standard of proof set in the McCleskey case. As a result, many instances of racial bias remained ignored in the courts, contributing to some of the worst racial disparities in the country, at least until the California Racial Justice Act was enacted in 2021.

The California Racial Justice Act

In 2020, Assemblymember Kalra authored AB 2542, the California Racial Justice Act, which prohibits the state from seeking or obtaining a criminal conviction or imposing a sentence based on race, ethnicity, or national origin. This was a prospective bill, meaning only judgments after the bill went into effect on January 1, 2021, were eligible for relief.

Through AB 2542, a person charged or convicted of a crime could challenge racial bias in their case by demonstrating evidence of the following:

  1. Racial bias from people involved in the case
  2. Racially discriminatory language during the trial
  3. Racial bias in jury selection
  4. Statistical racial disparities in charging, conviction, and sentencing

Additional Legislation

As a former public defender, Assemblymember Kalra has witnessed the injustice when systemic racism is allowed to be perpetrated in the courts, especially for the Black community. He authored the California Racial Justice Act in 2020 to address racial discrimination and has continued to author legislation to ensure the intent of the original bill is carried out. Below is a list of follow-up legislation:

  • AB 256 (2022): Also known as the California Racial Justice Act for All, this bill made AB 2542 retroactive and allowed challenges to racial bias in cases before January 1, 2021. Chapter 739, Statutes of 2022.
  • AB 1118 (2023): Clarified that RJA claims can be raised on appeal, or, if additional evidence is needed, permits individuals to request a stay of an appeal and remand to the trial court to file a motion. Also clarified that a case need not be set for trial to file an RJA motion. Chapter 464, Statutes of 2023.
  • AB 2065 (2024): Allowed better access to publicly available criminal justice data and required law enforcement agencies to share probation and police reports, regardless of the date they were prepared, with attorneys investigating a racial bias claim. Held on Suspense.
  • AB 1071 (2025): Affirmed the Legislature’s intent to create a low threshold for the appointment of counsel, improved access to discovery for petitioners to prove their claims, and ensured the process for habeas petitions was aligned with those in the RJA statute. This bill also made clear that if a violation of the RJA is found, a remedy must be applied and ensured judges were not limited as to the types of remedies they can impose, barring existing prohibitions under law. Chapter 721, Statutes of 2025.
  • AB 1958 (2026): Clarified that there are multiple ways to establish a disparity claim. AB 1958 also clarified the evidence disclosure requirements and made it explicit that no part of the criminal process is insulated from the RJA. Failed passage.

The Impact as Communities Fight for Racial Justice

The California Racial Justice Act gives individuals who have been charged with or convicted of a crime the ability to challenge racial bias in the criminal legal system and seek justice. While significant work remains, the RJA marked a major step forward in advancing racial equity and has since been strengthened through additional legislation that clarified and expanded its protections. For communities that have historically faced disproportionate racial discrimination, the RJA provides an important legal tool to address racial injustice in the courts. Since its enactment in 2020, many individuals have relied on the law to challenge racial bias, and in a landmark decision, the California Supreme Court recently overturned a death sentence for the first time under the RJA.

Want to look at the bill language? Search for each bill in California Legislative Information.